Moved Out of California? You May Still Owe California Income Tax!

Person reviewing financial documents and using a calculator at a desk

A California tax dispute involving a remote worker shows why moving to another state does not always end your California tax obligations—and why the California Supreme Court is now examining an important part of the law.

Imagine you have lived in Santa Monica for years.

You decide to move to Nevada. You sell your California home, move your family, obtain a Nevada driver’s license, and begin working from your new home.

You no longer commute to California. You have no California office. You believe you have left California’s income taxes behind.

But there is one detail: You still have customers in California.

Perhaps you are a software developer, consultant, graphic designer, accountant, or other self-employed professional. You perform all your work from Nevada, but some of the people paying you are in California.

Can California still tax the money you earn from those customers?

The answer is that California may claim the right to tax some of that income, even when you perform the work entirely outside the state.

However, a recent court decision has raised serious questions about one of the legal theories California has used to impose that tax.

To understand the issue, we need to start with two simple questions.

  1. Have You Really Moved Out of California?

Moving your belongings to another state does not automatically mean California will stop considering you a resident.

California generally looks at where you actually live, where your family lives, whether your absence is temporary, and where you maintain your most significant personal and business connections.

For more information, read our article on California residency audits and the tax risks they can create.

Consider two situations.

Example A: You permanently move to Nevada.

You sell your Santa Monica home, move your family and belongings, establish a permanent Nevada residence, and genuinely intend to live there.

These facts generally support the conclusion that you have become a California nonresident.

Example B: You temporarily stay in Nevada.

You rent an apartment in Nevada but keep your Santa Monica home, maintain most of your personal connections in California, and plan to return.

California may continue treating you as a resident.

Why does this distinction matter?

Because California residents generally pay California income tax on their taxable income from everywhere, including income earned outside California.

Nonresidents, by contrast, generally pay California income tax only on income considered to come from California sources.

That brings us to the second question.

  1. Even If You Are No Longer a Resident, Where Does Your Income Come From?

Suppose you genuinely move to Nevada and are no longer a California resident.

California generally cannot tax all your income simply because you used to live there.

But certain income may remain taxable in California.

Here are some common examples:

Income received after movingCan California still tax it?
Rent from your former Santa Monica homeGenerally yes. California rental property produces California-source income.
Profit from selling California real estateGenerally yes. The property is located in California.
Wages for days you physically work in CaliforniaGenerally yes. Those workdays generally produce California-source wages.
Wages for work performed entirely from NevadaGenerally no, even if your employer is in California, subject to special compensation rules.
Ordinary bank interest and stock dividendsGenerally no, unless connected to a California business or another exception.
Self-employment income from California customersPossibly. This is where the law becomes more complicated.

The last category is particularly important for freelancers, consultants, and people who operate their own businesses.

And it is the subject of our tax case.

  1. The Markowski Case: A Programmer Who Never Worked in California

In Appeal of Markowski, a taxpayer lived outside California and worked as a self-employed computer programmer.

During 2017, he wrote computer code for a company located in San Mateo, California.

He received $37,857 for his services.

The company issued him a Form 1099-MISC, and he reported the income on his federal tax return as self-employment income.

He did not file a California income tax return.

Why would he?

He was not a California resident, and he performed the work outside California.

But the California Franchise Tax Board disagreed.

The FTB determined that his income was taxable in California.

The taxpayer challenged the assessment before the California Office of Tax Appeals.

What did California decide?

The Office of Tax Appeals upheld California’s position.

It applied special rules for certain businesses operating across state lines.

Under those rules, income from business services can be assigned to the state where the customer receives the benefit of the services, rather than the state where the person physically performs the work.

Because the customer received the benefit in California, the OTA treated the programmer’s receipts as California-source business income.

In other words, California looked at where the customer received the benefit of the services, not where the programmer sat while writing the code.

The taxpayer’s federal Schedule C expenses were allowed in determining the taxable amount.

The surprising result: The programmer performed his work outside California, yet California taxed the income connected to his California customer.

But there is an important qualification.

The decision depended on treating his sole proprietorship as a business subject to California’s multistate apportionment rules. That legal foundation is now being challenged in another case.

We will return to that development shortly.

  1. Why Employees and Independent Contractors Can Be Taxed Differently

Imagine two former Santa Monica residents who both move to Nevada.

Both work from their Nevada homes.

Both provide computer programming services to companies in California.

But one is an employee, while the other operates an independent business.

Their California income tax treatment may be different.

QuestionW-2 employeeIndependent contractor
Lives in NevadaYesYes
Performs all work in NevadaYesYes
Works for a California companyYesYes
Where is income generally sourced?Where the employee physically performs the servicesMay depend on business sourcing and apportionment rules
California income tax?Generally no on wages earned entirely in NevadaCalifornia may assert tax on income connected to California customers

For an ordinary employee, the general rule is relatively straightforward.

If you live in Nevada and physically perform all your employment services there, your wages generally are not California-source income merely because your employer is located in California.

For independent contractors, however, the analysis may be different.

California has argued that certain self-employment income should be assigned according to where the customer receives the benefit of the services.

That distinction explains why the programmer in Markowski faced California income tax even though he performed his work elsewhere.

But does California have the legal authority to apply those particular business rules to every individual sole proprietor?

That question is now before the California Supreme Court.

  1. A Major New Development: The Garcia-Rojas Case

In 2026, another taxpayer challenged California’s approach.

This time, the taxpayer was a radiologist living in Texas.

He worked remotely for a California-based medical company, reviewing medical images and preparing reports from his Texas home.

California sought to tax a portion of his income using the same general type of multistate business-apportionment theory involved in Markowski.

The taxpayer challenged that treatment.

What happened in court?

On May 1, 2026, the California Court of Appeal ruled against the Franchise Tax Board’s position on the record presented.

The court concluded that the FTB had not demonstrated that the radiologist operated what tax law calls a unitary business.

That term generally refers to business activities sufficiently connected or integrated to be treated as one business for purposes of allocating income among states.

The court questioned whether the FTB could apply that concept to an individual operating a single sole proprietorship performing one business activity.

The court also criticized the reasoning of an earlier administrative decision that California had relied upon in similar disputes.

Importantly, the court did not rule that California could never tax the radiologist’s income.

It rejected the particular legal justification the FTB had established in that proceeding and left open the possibility of other grounds for taxation.

What happened next?

On September 3, 2026, the California Supreme Court agreed to review Garcia-Rojas v. Franchise Tax Board.

The question before the Supreme Court is whether a nonresident’s business can qualify as a unitary business under the applicable regulation when it consists of a single sole proprietorship.

As of November 2026, that question remains unresolved.

This means that Markowski illustrates how California has applied its tax rules, but it should not be understood as a final, binding answer for every remote independent contractor.

  1. What Does This Mean If You Move From Santa Monica to Nevada?

Consider three ordinary situations.

Situation 1: You move to Nevada but keep your Santa Monica rental property.

You genuinely become a Nevada resident.

However, you continue collecting rent from your California property.

California generally can tax the rental income because the property is located in California.

Situation 2: You move to Nevada but remain a W-2 employee of a California company.

You perform all your work from Nevada.

Generally, California cannot tax those wages solely because your employer is located in California.

However, compensation attributable to earlier California work, such as certain bonuses or stock-based compensation, may require separate analysis.

Situation 3: You move to Nevada and operate a consulting business serving California customers.

You perform all your work from Nevada and receive payments from California customers.

California may assert that some of your business income is taxable in California under its sourcing and apportionment rules.

But whether the particular unitary-business theory applies to your sole proprietorship is now a disputed legal question.

These three situations show why the answer depends on the type of income you receive—not simply where you live.

  1. Is There a Minimum Amount You Must Earn Before California Can Tax You?

Many taxpayers assume that California cannot tax them unless they earn a substantial amount of money from California.

That is not necessarily true.

California has different rules for determining whether a person must file a return, whether a business is considered to be doing business in California, and how much income is attributable to California.

These are not interchangeable tests.

For example, California’s economic-nexus thresholds for businesses do not create a universal exemption for every nonresident earning less than a particular amount from California customers.

Likewise, the existence of California-source income does not automatically mean that every taxpayer must file a return. California has separate filing requirements based on income, filing status, age, and other circumstances.

There is no single dollar amount that answers every California nonresident income tax question.

The nature of the income and the applicable legal rules must be examined first.

  1. What If California Already Taxed Your Remote Consulting Income?

The Garcia-Rojas litigation may be particularly important for nonresidents who previously paid California income tax on self-employment income earned entirely outside the state.

If the tax was imposed under the unitary-business theory now under review, the taxpayer may have grounds to examine whether a refund claim is appropriate.

However, the Supreme Court has not yet resolved the issue.

And taxpayers must be mindful of the deadlines for filing refund claims.

Waiting for the Supreme Court to decide the case could create a separate problem if the applicable refund deadline expires in the meantime.

Depending on the circumstances, a protective refund claim may be worth considering to preserve the taxpayer’s rights while the litigation continues.

A protective claim does not guarantee a refund. It is a procedural step that may help preserve a timely claim while an unresolved legal issue is being decided.

Whether a protective refund claim is appropriate depends on the taxpayer’s circumstances, the tax years involved, and the applicable filing deadlines.

  1. Three Questions to Ask Before Moving Out of California

If you are considering leaving Santa Monica or have already moved, ask yourself:

  1. Have I genuinely become a resident of another state?

California may continue taxing your worldwide income if you remain a California resident for tax purposes.

  1. Will I continue receiving income from California?

Rental income, real estate gains, California workdays, and certain business income may remain taxable after you move.

  1. Am I a W-2 employee or an independent contractor?

The distinction can substantially affect how California determines the source of your income.

For independent contractors, the additional question is whether California’s business-apportionment rules legally apply to their particular activities.

That is the issue highlighted by Markowski and the pending Garcia-Rojas litigation.

The Bottom Line

Moving out of California does not necessarily mean leaving California income taxes behind.

A genuine nonresident generally is not taxed by California on all worldwide income, but California may still tax income from California sources.

For rental property, California real estate sales, and wages earned while physically working in California, the general rules are relatively established.

For independent contractors working entirely outside California while serving California customers, however, an important legal dispute remains unresolved.

Appeal of Markowski shows how California has sought to tax that income.

Garcia-Rojas v. Franchise Tax Board shows why that approach is being challenged.

The practical lesson: Before moving out of California—or assuming you no longer owe California income tax—understand both your residency status and the source of your income.

If you need guidance regarding California residency or income tax obligations, contact Us.

Cases Discussed

Appeal of Markowski, 2024-OTA-139 (California Office of Tax Appeals, nonprecedential).

Garcia-Rojas v. Franchise Tax Board, California Court of Appeal, May 1, 2026; California Supreme Court review granted September 3, 2026, Case No. S297035.

Leon Nazarian, CPA, JD
Santa Monica Tax Attorney & Certified Public Accountant
Federal and California Tax Representation

https://tax-cpa-911.com

This article is intended for general educational purposes and does not constitute individualized tax or legal advice. California residency, income sourcing, apportionment, and refund rights depend on the taxpayer’s specific circumstances and applicable law.

Not Registered in California? Even $121 in Employee Wages Could Trigger an $800 Tax!

Business professional reviewing financial documents.

A 2025 California tax case reveals how a small amount of business activity can create a surprisingly large state tax obligation.

 

Imagine that you own a business located outside California.

Your company has no California office, no storefront, and no substantial California sales. However, you hire someone who lives in California to perform occasional clerical work.

During the entire year, you pay that employee only $121.

Would you expect California to charge your business an $800 annual tax?

That is exactly the issue addressed in Appeal of Metro Mortgage Group, LLC, a 2025 California Office of Tax Appeals decision.

The answer may surprise many business owners.

 

  1. The First Question: Is Your Company Registered in California?

Many out-of-state business owners know that registering their companies to do business in California can trigger California tax obligations.

For example, a Colorado LLC that registers with the California Secretary of State generally becomes subject to California’s $800 annual LLC tax, even if it earns little or no income in the state.

But what happens when an out-of-state company has not registered in California?

Does that automatically mean the company owes no California tax?

No.

California law provides another, independent basis for imposing the tax: actually doing business in California.

A business may become subject to California’s minimum tax because of what it does in the state, regardless of whether registration is established.

That distinction is the central lesson of the Metro Mortgage case.

 

  1. What Happened in the Metro Mortgage Case?

Metro Mortgage Group, LLC was a company organized in Colorado and treated as an S corporation for federal income tax purposes.

During 2019, the company employed an individual in California who performed occasional clerical work.

The total California wages paid to that employee were just $121.

The company did not file the required California tax return.

The California Franchise Tax Board (FTB) determined that the company’s activities constituted doing business in California and assessed the applicable $800 annual tax, along with penalties and fees.

Metro Mortgage challenged the assessment.

The company’s position was essentially that its California activities were too insignificant to justify imposing the tax.

The dispute eventually reached the California Office of Tax Appeals.

 

  1. The Important Legal Question: What Does “Doing Business” Mean?

California Revenue and Taxation Code §23101(a) generally defines doing business as actively engaging in a transaction for financial or pecuniary gain or profit.

In ordinary language, the question is:

Was the company conducting business activity in California, even on a very small scale?

Importantly, this definition does not require a company to earn thousands of dollars in California revenue or maintain a permanent office in the state.

The company’s actual activities matter.

In Metro Mortgage’s situation, the California employee performed work for the business, even though the amount of compensation was extremely small.

The OTA concluded that the company’s activities were sufficient to constitute doing business in California.

 

  1. Only $121 in Wages—But an $800 Tax?

Consider how surprising the result can be.

ItemAmount
California employee wages for the year$121
California annual minimum tax$800
Tax compared with employee wagesApproximately 6.6 times the wages

The company paid just $121 for California employee services, but the annual minimum tax was $800.

Why?

Because the tax was not calculated as a percentage of the employee’s wages.

It was an annual minimum tax triggered by the company’s California tax status.

Once the OTA determined that the company was doing business in California, the minimum tax applied.

The fact that the employee earned only $121 did not eliminate the obligation.

 

  1. Registration Versus Actual Business Activity: Two Different Ways to Trigger the Tax

This is the most important distinction for out-of-state business owners.

SituationPotential California tax consequence
An out-of-state LLC registers to do business in California.Registration generally creates an independent California tax obligation.
An out-of-state LLC does not register but actually conducts business in California.Its activities may independently trigger California tax obligations.
An out-of-state LLC has no California registration and no California business activity.The $800 tax generally does not apply merely because the company exists in another state.

The critical lesson is that avoiding California registration does not necessarily mean avoiding California taxation.

The Metro Mortgage decision illustrates the activity-based rule.

The OTA did not need to establish or rely on the company’s California Secretary of State registration status to conclude that its activities constituted doing business.

The published decision does not establish whether Metro Mortgage was registered or unregistered. Its significance lies in the court’s analysis of actual business activity.

 

  1. What About the Penalties?

The $800 tax was not the only issue.

Because the company had not filed the required California return, the FTB also imposed penalties and fees.

The OTA upheld the annual tax and certain associated charges.

However, it granted relief from the FTB demand penalty based on reasonable cause.

This is another important lesson:

A taxpayer may remain responsible for the underlying tax while qualifying for relief from a particular penalty.

Tax liability and penalty relief are separate questions.

Even when the tax itself cannot be avoided, the facts may justify challenging some additional charges.

 

  1. What Does This Mean for Businesses With Remote Employees?

This case is particularly relevant to companies operating across state lines.

Today, businesses frequently hire remote workers, part-time assistants, bookkeepers, administrative employees, and other individuals who work from home.

Consider the following example.

A Nevada company has no physical office in California. It hires a California resident to perform occasional administrative tasks from home.

The employee earns only $500 during the year.

The company assumes that such a small amount of activity cannot create a California tax obligation.

That assumption may be incorrect.

Depending on the company’s legal structure and circumstances, the employee’s activities may establish that the company is doing business in California.

The amount of compensation alone is not necessarily decisive.

Before hiring employees in another state, business owners should consider the potential state income tax, franchise tax, payroll, and registration consequences.

 

  1. Does Every Out-of-State Business Automatically Owe $800?

No.

The result depends on the company’s legal structure, California activities, applicable statutory provisions, and any available exceptions.

For example, the rules applicable to LLCs taxed as partnerships may differ from those applicable to LLCs taxed as corporations.

Similarly, California has statutory economic-nexus thresholds, but those thresholds do not necessarily protect a business whose actual activities independently satisfy the general definition of doing business under §23101(a).

The key is to examine the nature of the company’s California activities rather than assume that minimal revenue or payroll eliminates the tax obligation.

 

  1. Why Both CPA and Tax Attorney Experience Can Matter

State tax disputes often involve two different questions.

First: Does the company have a California filing or tax obligation?

Second: If the state has assessed tax, penalties, or fees, are those assessments legally justified?

As both a Certified Public Accountant and Tax Attorney, Leon Nazarian, CPA, JD, assists taxpayers and businesses in evaluating tax reporting requirements, responding to tax examinations, and challenging disputed tax assessments through available administrative and legal procedures.

For out-of-state companies, understanding California’s definition of doing business before a dispute arises can help avoid unexpected liabilities.

The Bottom Line

An out-of-state business does not necessarily escape California’s $800 annual minimum tax simply because it has not registered to do business in California.

In Appeal of Metro Mortgage Group, LLC, the California Office of Tax Appeals concluded that a company’s California employee activities were sufficient to establish that it was doing business in the state—even though the employee received only $121 in wages.

The case demonstrates that actual business activity, not just formal registration, can create a California tax obligation.

For companies employing remote workers or conducting even occasional business activities in California, that distinction can be expensive to overlook.

For more information, read our blog on California residency audits and related tax risks.

Case Reference: Appeal of Metro Mortgage Group, LLC, 2025-OTA-093SCP, California Office of Tax Appeals (nonprecedential).

Legal Authority: California Revenue and Taxation Code §§17941 and 23101.

Leon Nazarian, CPA, JD
Santa Monica Tax Attorney & Certified Public Accountant
Tax CPA 911 | https://tax-cpa-911.com

This article is provided for general educational purposes and does not constitute individualized tax or legal advice. California tax obligations depend on the taxpayer’s entity classification, activities, and applicable law.